Panino Sportivo
On Amsterdam between 120th and 121st. Located below Plimpton.
Apparently, the Nutella hot chocolate is "to die for".
Map
<googlemap lat="40.809847" lon="-73.958695" type="map" zoom="16" width="500" height="300" controls="small"> 40.809847, -73.958695, Panino Sportivo </googlemap>